Sunday, October 28, 2007

Michael Fried and Courbet's Burial at Ornans

Michael Fried provides us with a new reading of Gustave Courbet’s The Burial at Ornans of 1849-50 using evidence presented by the image itself as the basis for his interpretation. He is concerned with what he describes as Courbet’s determination to create an “antitheatrical relationship” between the painting and its viewer (636). He then proceeds to refute what he characterizes as the 4 cruxes of previous readings of this painting: the additive mode of composition, the juxtaposition of discrete, self sufficient entities with no internal connection; 17th c. Dutch and Spanish painting as possible sources for the Burial; Baudelaire’s “Salon of 1846” as a connection to the black costumes of the rural bourgeoisie shown in the painting; and the painting as reflecting the social and political developments occurring at the time it was made. This refers to T. J. Clark’s emphasis on social, historical and political context in his book “Image of the People: Gustave Courbet and the 1848 Revolution.” Although Fried calls Clark’s work “the most original study of Courbet to appear in many years” (637), he says the political significance of Clark’s claims is modest. He also faults Clark for barely discussing the pictures themselves.

Fried’s own interpretation focuses on only a few of the elements of the painting: the serpentine path of the mourners, the skewed orientation of the open grave, and the exact location of Courbet’s friend Max Bouchon within the painting. Fried traces a history of possible alternative sources for the serpentine path citing Courbet’s early landscapes of the 1840’s showing the same terrain, and caricatures of processions of recognizable figures in Le Journal pour rire. In The Burial, Courbet uses the serpentine path to emphasize the lateral orientation of the procession of larger than life sized figures moving from left to right and left again across the broad expanse of the painting. They become compressed from 3-D to 2-D pushing toward the front of the picture plane. On the right, the bodies of 15 figures become a black mass differentiated only by their heads, hats and handkerchiefs. Also important to Fried’s argument are his speculations on Courbet’s treatment of the grave. He uses as a point of comparison Caravaggio’s Supper at Emmaus c. 1597 in which the gestures of the figures project into our space dissolving the boundary between the painting and the viewer, suggesting that both spaces are equally present to our senses. This plus the use of chiaroscuro heighten the dramatic effect of the painting. Fried calls this Baroque illusionism (661). It can be described as a theatrical effect. In opposition to this is Coubet’s treatment of the open grave at the bottom center of The Burial. It is treated with minimal illusionistic effect undermining the bottom framing edge and literally giving the viewer opposite the grave no ground on which to stand. Instead of projecting into the viewer’s space, the viewer is subsumed into the space of the painting. The viewer is not just an “eye” witnessing the illusion, he or she is drawn bodily into the image destroying the traditional notion of spectatorship. In addition to the lateral orientation of the procession of mourners described above, there is a vertical axis emphasized by the crucifix and the line of figures below it. The crucifix leads your eye to the man holding it, identified as the peasant Colard, who is staring out from the picture. Completing this vertical line is the dark haired boy holding a bucket. This boy’s red hat points to the yellow haired boy behind him and to his left. The second boy is looking up at the pallbearer to his left, whose hat, Fried suggests, has been jostled by the boy’s candle. Directly above the pallbearer’s dark hat is the head of Courbet’s friend Max Bouchon. So an acute angle leads your eye from the vertical axis to the head of Bouchon. Fried makes much of the significance of oblique angles in Courbet’s paintings.

Fried identifies two possible points of view outside of the painting. The first is directly opposite the open grave. He calls this (no) view, the view of the generalized viewer (Fried’s term is the beholder tout court.) A second position is implied by the skewed angle of the open grave. The fact that we can only see into the right side of the pit suggests this position is to the left of the open grave and Colard’s stare further pinpoints this position as directly in line with his intent gaze. Fried calls this the position of the painter/beholder, a specific viewer. Colard looks at the painter/beholder who deflects this gaze and looks at Bouchon instead. So the looking is not reciprocal. Fried conjectures that Bouchon is the beginning of the procession to the grave. If we imagine the painter/viewer, in this case Courbet, projecting himself bodily into the representation of Bouchon (with whom he identifies because of their friendship), then Courbet joins the procession at its source, enters the painting and obliterates his own spectatorship. Both Fried and T. J. Clark see Bouchon as a pivotal figure although T. J. Clark's interest is in Bouchon’s political views and not in where he was placed within the painting.

Fried says his views are based on conjecture, they may not be convincing, may contradict some of his earlier positions and may fail to answer some basic questions. Although I am not sure I agree with all of his arguments, they are thought provoking and open the discourse to new possibilities.

The readings we have done so far increase our understanding of Fried’s views. Even though Freud and Lacan are not mentioned directly, Fried describes ambivalences within Courbet’s painting, such as the merging of the artist into the painting and his resistance against this merging as a reaction formation, a Freudian term meaning the blocking of a desire by its opposite (See Introduction to Critical Theory http://www.cla.purdue.edu/English/Theory/psychoanalysis). His 2 nonreciprocal views of the cross bearer Colard staring out of the painting and the painter beholder avoiding that stare to look at Bouchon instead is reminiscent of Lacan’s eye and the gaze (“You never look at me from the place from which I see you”). The extreme strategy of Courbet projecting himself bodily into a painting can be seen as a social and political fact with Foucauldian implications (see note 55, p.677). It also exemplifies the phenomenological approach of Merleau Ponty in which the material world is experienced through the body and not just through the eye or the Cartesian mind. And instead of viewing T.J. Clark’s contextual approach and Fried’s more formalist methodology as antithetical to each other, Cixous, Butler, Bhabha and Munoz propose models where contradictions can be seen as complements coexisting simultaneously within a larger discourse.

No comments: