Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Fried and Formalism

I found this to be a refreshing article in light of most of the art historical texts we have read this semester. This text combined introduced, accepted, as well as challenged, the ideological socio-political argument T.J. Clark had made of The Burial at Ornans. Then, Fried proceeded in an in-depth argument of two separate beholders of the painting. One is the tout court and the other is a specific spectator to the left side of the painting. I have to admit that I was more influenced by the tout court analysis as I felt that myself, as a spectator, were situated within the grave. However, if I was standing in front of the 22 ft x 9 ft painting I believe my belief as to whether the beholder was in the center could be challened and I might feel that there is an outside spectator to the left.

However, I did enjoy the Vasarian-style analysis of the non-illusionistic quality of The Burial of Ornans vs the illusionistic, chiaroscuro quality of the Carravagio painting Supper at Emmaus. Because the grave portrays a minimalistic, suppressive illusion, its gives the effect, for me, of being Realistic. And this suppression of illusion is shown within the non-Romanticized landscape in the background of the painting. This suppression of illusion is what I feel is most important to Realism's formal qualities in terms of usage of light in paintings by Courbet. The range of light is compressed to devoid the emotional response of the tout court or the outside spectator that was triggered by Romantics such as David Casper Friedrich. It is kind of ironic to believe that illusion=distance and realism=proxmity as most people link romanticism with the inner spiritual and realism with reality. If I was to be in the "subjectivity camp", how would I not be able to defend that illusion=proximity and realism=distance????

Throughout the text, Fried contradicts himself by validating his first theory of the painter-beholder and the outside spectator to the left of the canvas based upon various assumptions such as the skewed orientantion of the open grave and the figure with the crucifix looking gazing outside the canvas. But I believe the multiple analyses are valid because it challenges whether this is a window onto reality or a flat surface facing the beholder. In doing so, we are subjected by the gaze of being looked at, situated within the grave, and as neither within the grave or being looked at because the left side of the painting contains figures that gazes outside of our view.

Lastly, I enjoyed the debate at the end of class yesterday. I think that we are all maturing in our belief systems and representations in our desire to be art historians. But I believe that HISTORY is very important and that it should never be forgotten. It can be valid to use that HISTORY as evidence to support a critical analysis of an art show such as the Jeff Wall show at SFMOMA or any other contemporary arts exhibition within the SF Bay Area museums.

See y'all next week. Ciao.

No comments: