Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Updates 9/5/2007


Hi All,

Thank you for your good thoughts here. I look forward to next week's. I know it may have been tough going but believe me, semiotics is necessary and will make the rest of the course easier to understand.

Sara tells me that her book has not yet arrived. If this is a problem I'll continue to scan and post the readings. Also, Collete tells me she ordered the book but it is the wrong edition. This is the second edition and you can identify this edition by the cover. (Sorry about the confusion, I imagined this book to be a best-seller. . . .)

Best,

Dr. B

Tuesday, September 4, 2007

What is a sign?

After reading the two articles I found myself wondering how do I use this in my own life? The first question I had was how do I use semiotics? This first thing that poped into my head was that we are trained to know what different thing are / mean just by the sign. For instance the two golden arches we all know what the reapresents (fast unhealthy food), and the reason what we know what the golden archs represent is because we are trained to know.

In the Peirce article I thought it was interesting that the reason behind things happening was because other thing that we might not even be aware of happen first. I agreed with Peirce on how an interest grows for the monment that one might want something and the steps that one should take in order to get it. for instance money. We all want money but in order to get it we have to take different stepps to aquire it. Peirce writes the we have to have a primary, secondary, and mediatory interest inorder to get waht we want.

What is a Sign?

Start with the Basics.

Peirce's perspective on our sense of reality seems to come from the reaction of ones feelings bouncing off the other. Just as a mirror will give a reflection, our feelings are based upon only the comparison of each emotion when compared to another. Happy is never known that it is 'happy' until we have felt the opposition-mad, sad. With that said, Peirce says that we don't really know the significant's of anything until it is placed in a known context that we can identify with. Just like the map example: one would never known where anything chunk of land was, unless we identify it next to previously acquired knowledge. I also noticed he likes to exemplify points in sets of three's. For instance, the three interests; 1st interest is just for the thing itself, 2nd its reactions with other things, and 3rd is the mediatory interest. When coming to the third, this marks it as a sign or representation. For me this signifies that an object first starts with a basic interest in something, such as child would be to a shiny, red ball. Then we chose to compare it to things that we have previously viewed; maybe we like this ball more than that brown ball from yesterday, it appeals to more of our senses. And lastly we start to be more inquisitive, like what are we going to do with this ball and where will it lead me, or why am I attracted to it in the first place. This is a very basic observation, but one must break it down I feel to truly understand anything beyond what is being talked about. Just like he states, "Every intellectual operation involves a triad of symbols."

Photography & Signs - Objectivity vs. Subjectivity

It appears to me that Barthes' article challenges the divisions of photographs (Birth, Death, Work, etc.) because their singular wording produces generic Feelings (Peirce). So, in result, we are left without a Reaction that does not produce Thinking (Peirce).
How do we relate these singular words to images though? However, when viewing the photographs, whether in a book or on a wall in a museum, are we supposed to look at the image to produce signs from intution or are we supposed to look at the title before viewing the photograph in order to be given signs as they are presented to us?

Barthes states "Whether or not the child is borne with ease or difficulty....:this is what your Exhibitions should be telling people, instead of an eternal lyricism of birth." Must we objectively be informed via lingual signs what Birth is or are we subjectively supposed to interpret the many different things that happen as a result of birth while viewing a photograph?

In essence, rather than looking for signs in titles or wording, I think we should be looking for signs in imagery. As Barthes states, in Camera Lucida, a photograph that pricks me is one that I should enjoyfully immerse myself with. And, as a result, isn't a prick a Feeling, producing a Reaction, that results in a Thought as Peirce states in "What is a Sign?

Monday, September 3, 2007

What makes a sign a sign

After reading the articles, its my understanding that the best way to approach semiotics is to understand the different states of mind as discussed in Peirce's article. By being aware of the three different states of mind; feeling, reacting, and thinking; I can understand the ways in which we interpret signs.

Its interesting to think, as discussed in Peirce's articles, that all signs can essentially only appeal to the viewers experience. He states, "no place can be described, except relatively to some known place". In order to understand signs we have to be able to relate them to something else. The three types of signs; likenesses, indications, and symbols; all rely on the viewers experience to guide the interpretation. The example of a likeness in Peirce's articles is that since a zebra looks similar to a donkey it is similar in disposition. In order to make this connection with the zebra and donkey, one would have to be familiar with a donkey. For indications, there is the example of a man with a rolling gate and he being assumed to be a sailor. Again, for that interpretation of the sign to be made, the viewer would have to have experience with sailors. Someone that had never encountered a sailor would not make the connection. Essentially, it seems that what makes a sign a sign is the viewer being able to make the appropriate connections based on their personal experiences.

Thank God for Barthes

Pierce gives us three progressive (I want to use the word “reactions” here, although it’s similarities to the correct word decrease its value, so I need to use a word whose differences reflect the actual meaning that I am intending) responses to “things”: Feeling, Reaction and Thinking. These are the requirements for a sign to be a sign. Further, there are three types of signs: likenesses or icons, indices, and symbols. Pierce then goes into a systematic discussion of what each of these signs is and how we can identify them.
And then there is Saussure, who further describes for us what exists between a thought and a word by way of the sound of a word. The best description as far as I am concerned is that the thought lives on one side of a piece of paper while the sound lives on the other side, and one can not slice them apart. Or the relationship lies in the nebulous area in between the two sides of the paper. Therefore, when one changes so does the other. He also discusses the relationships between sounds, in particular the negative relationship between them – or rather that their differences are what gives them meaning (and also how arbitrary the assigned sounds are to each word.
For me, one of the most interesting aspects of all of this is this sentence of Saussure’s, “The community is necessary if values that owe their existence solely to usage and general acceptance are to be set up; by himself the individual is incapable of fixing a single value.” How intriguing that we all do this together in some way – either by choosing or conforming or something else! But, also it is related to Barthes discussion. Saussure says “If words stood for pre-existing concepts, they would all have exact equivalents in meaning from one language to the next; but this is not true.” Thus, each community comes up with its own set of values. Barthes asks a couple of times for us to imagine what different communities might think about The Family of Man Exhibition. Within the exhibition the language used by one community only works to serve that community by way of telling its story or myth. It ends up working against other communities (the family of Emmet Till and the North African workers of the Goutte d’Or district in Paris) by way of ignoring them. I think it is here that Barthes is saying that photography and language (or the community that has chosen them) has failed to communicate a truth in this particular instance.


Tid Bit:
If you printed your Saussure / Barthes reading from the course website, please note the funny symbols at the top of the first page. This is where Dr. B hand wrote F. Saussure and R. Barthes. However, the scanning program in the VRL chose to interpret the letter signs in a completely different way – or how it understood the signs.

questioning/interpreting: a quick preliminary mini-blog

Peirce what is a sign? Barthes encoding and decoding?
Sensing feeling thinking interpreting
This stands for that and that is not this
If one action is a means to bring about a result, does it then mean the use of signs was developed to bring action?
Three kinds of “action makers”? -- imitation born out of likeness, physically connect indication to force attention, and symbols associated with their meanings through usage (like my words here).
To be successful a sign/symbol/action maker must be able to be repeated and understood in this repetition in addition to being able to be connected with previous experience.
For a sign/symbol/action maker to be understood, it must have a previous experience to be related to as our new knowledge, our new experience, our new action, needs this previous understanding to contextualize what is new.
Anything that startles us forces our attention and becomes a sign.
The letters to create the word FLY when put together F-L-Y then create a symbol for action, of a moment, of a though, of an experience.
F-L-Y likeness, index, symbol
F-L-Y analogous sensation, physical connectivity, idea creation
F-L-Y is universal
group determines symbol
group socializes symbol
individual recognizes symbol
individual regurgitates symbol
symbol is reproduced and grows and
becomes a new symbol
a new meaning
a new deSIGNation

Sunday, September 2, 2007

Saussure, Peirce, Barthes and The Family of Man

Thanks Julia and Jenny for your thoughts on the readings. I was having difficulty knowing where to begin with my own reactions and your entries have helped to stimulate my thinking.

For me it is Saussure who defines the system of semiotics that gives rise to meaning and Peirce who refines it. Barthes then shows how it can be applied to popular culture, in this case the photographic exhibit The Family of Man.

I just have a few observations. I was interested in seeing how Saussure defined value. After stating that the meaning of a word can't be understood in isolation, that it can only be determined extrinsically, by what is around it, he illustrates this point by defining value in precisely this manner. He never states, “value is…” He hones in on the meaning by describing it from different points of view. He first looks at value conceptually by distinguishing between value and signification. (Value is determined by dissimilar things that can be exchanged i.e. a franc for bread- or by comparing similar things -paper currency and its' equivalent in coins). From a material point of view, value is not to be confused with the material element (sound, phonemes) used to create it.

I didn't get from the reading that Peirce thinks of the photograph as being a failure as a sign. As he describes it, it is not purely a likeness or an index but can be both at the same time. It bears a resemblance to what is depicted and also can be evidence of the presence of the thing photographed at some point in the past.

Regarding Barthes and The Family of Man. I have a copy of a MOMA publication based on the exhibition that I'll bring to class for anyone who'd like to see it. The quote on the first page is Genesis 1:3 “And God said, let there be light” illustrating a picture of the moon over water. Under the title “The Family of Man” is the hyperbolic description: “The greatest photographic exhibition of all time… created by Edward Steichen for the Museum of Modern Art” . Immediately the audience is set up to view this as event on a par with the Christian version of God's creation of the earth. I remember being awestruck when I first saw this. To me it was revelatory to have Barthes deconstruct the exhibition and bring out the ideology hidden there. Today, decades later, I can see his point that that the original meaning inherent in each of the photos has been effaced by the ideological work they now perform. The cultural, social, economic, and historically specific point of view of the people, ethnic groups, countries, traditions presented have been glossed over and unequal hierarchies of power, colonialism, exploitation, discrimination etc. that underpin them have been defused. The original meanings of the photos cannot be understood because like Saussure's words, they have been taken out of context. They have become new signifiers combined with new concepts to create a narrative about the universal and essential nature of humankind, a "myth" based on the values of the petit bourgeois that Barthes makes explicit.

Blogger: ARTH277 Seminar in Historiography/Theories of Art and Criticism - Manage Posts

Blogger: ARTH277 Seminar in Historiography/Theories of Art and Criticism - Manage Posts

Happy Sign Readings

While reading this week's articles, I tried to keep in mind the theme connecting all of the readings together, semiology. I will admit that it took several reads of some paragraphs, even some sentences to conclude anything from the abstract thinking of the authors. In the end I concluded that a sign, as simply stated by Saussure, "is something that stands for something else." More so, however, a sign represents a process. It is a process of reasoning and ordering to ultimately produce a truth, or an answer.

One of the ways Saussure writes of this process is by way of determining the values of words. Different values are placed on words in every language. However, the meaning of a word in one language cannot be a definitive meaning of a similar word in another language. A value must be determined and then further assessed in relation to other words in order to come up with the signification of the words, or the result of the combination and positioning of values.

I also found it interesting how Peirce and Barthes seemed to reject photographs as being acceptable signs. Instead, they saw photographs as a way of only capturing the immediate moment, but nothing else. There is no way to derive any indication of a past or predict any type of future of the photographed subject. According to Peirce the result of a picture is only a likeness of what is being photographed. A photo can only transfer a physical likeness because we know nothing else than what we're shown. You could say something about the physical resemblance of one photograph to another, but could not conclude any personal similarities based only on a physical likeness.

I'm looking forward to reviewing and discussing the articles further in class. Happy sign readings. . .