Tuesday, October 30, 2007

In Michael Fried's "The Structure of Beholding in Courbet's Burial at Ornans" he discusses the relationship between the painting and the beholder that is presented in the work. He mentions that Courbet is attempting something new as most works of that time attempt to exclude the viewer. This relationship between the beholder and the painting is emphasized by the lifesize scale of the work. The crowded of the figures demands our attention and conveys a sense of confrontation.

Fried discusses four points about the painting that are typically accepted theories. The first is that the painting has an additive composition that is based on juxtaposition. Next he says that the composition of the painting is usually attributed to influence from Dutch group portraits, 17th century Spanish painting, or 1830's woodcuts. He mentions the black costumes of all the figures as being thought of as a representation of the borgeoisie, and that it represents the ambiguos social situation between the peasantry and upper class.

Fried then moves on to discuss his own thoughts on Burial at Ornans. He denies that the composistion is purely additive and says it is processional. The overall scene implies a slow continuous movement. This processional composition is emphasized by the wide format of the space. And the mass of black contributes by creating a collective dift throughout. I think Fried's article is well organized and easy to read. He explains all aspects of the painting well and the different ideas about it that exist before presenting his own.

No comments: