A new subject this week-Subjectivity. To get myself grounded, I checked my dictionary and found subjectivity defined as “existing in the mind; belonging to the thinking subject” (Random House Webster’s College Dictionary, 1996). So began my journey into the topic of subjectivity. The introduction laid out the notion that subjectivity is in opposition to the humanist belief that the “human individual is conceived as a unified centre of control from which meaning emanates.” Subjectivity goes against the Descartes’ dictum “I think, therefore I am.” The readings show how factors such as history, society, and culture contribute to our individual identity. This is contrary to the humanist belief that “identity and being are mutually dependent factors of individual existence” (73).
Freud’s entry is interesting as he details our earliest thought process as chronicled through observations of his grandson. On the basis of one short reading, it’s hard for me to agree with Freud’s theory that we are seeking to master our loss but it’s clear that a young age we begin the thought process for whatever reason (I’d like to know how many other children he studied or if he based his theory on observations of his grandson alone). External factors contribute to what we think. I have the advantage of making similar observations through videos of my young nephew. He knows when he’s a good boy, a silly boy, or into something he shouldn’t be simply by the tone of my sister-in-law’s voice. This leads into Lacan’s discussion about the mirror stage. As evidenced by my sister-in-law and nephew, the inflection or tone of language affects our thought process and how we identify ourselves. When my sister-in-law says “You’re a silly boy” my nephew shakes his head and makes a face to show agreement or confirmation.
As Fanon demonstrates, we are not something until it is pointed out to us. We are not boy, girl, white, black until we are called those things. Something that went through my mind while reading these selections is the line from South Pacific about how “you must be carefully taught” to be prejudice. We do not notice or are concerned with our differences until others call them to our attention which for most of us happens at a very young age.
Institutional factors that influence our being is interesting. While reading Foucault’s description of “plague” control enforced in cities, I couldn’t help but wonder about the current administration and how they must wish they could enforce similar controls on us.
After this week's readings its hard to believe that our thinking and thought process is not influenced by our surroundings. It seems that the only way to keep with the humanist notion that we are the sole author of our thoughts we would have to be live in a vacuum, completely isolated from anything else.
Tuesday, October 2, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment