Tuesday, September 4, 2007

Photography & Signs - Objectivity vs. Subjectivity

It appears to me that Barthes' article challenges the divisions of photographs (Birth, Death, Work, etc.) because their singular wording produces generic Feelings (Peirce). So, in result, we are left without a Reaction that does not produce Thinking (Peirce).
How do we relate these singular words to images though? However, when viewing the photographs, whether in a book or on a wall in a museum, are we supposed to look at the image to produce signs from intution or are we supposed to look at the title before viewing the photograph in order to be given signs as they are presented to us?

Barthes states "Whether or not the child is borne with ease or difficulty....:this is what your Exhibitions should be telling people, instead of an eternal lyricism of birth." Must we objectively be informed via lingual signs what Birth is or are we subjectively supposed to interpret the many different things that happen as a result of birth while viewing a photograph?

In essence, rather than looking for signs in titles or wording, I think we should be looking for signs in imagery. As Barthes states, in Camera Lucida, a photograph that pricks me is one that I should enjoyfully immerse myself with. And, as a result, isn't a prick a Feeling, producing a Reaction, that results in a Thought as Peirce states in "What is a Sign?

No comments: