Monday, October 15, 2007

Gender and Race

Freud
Freud’s theory as to the cause of psychical impotence is enlightening in the respect that it illustrates why he has been seen as ahead of his time. This does not mean that I agree with his arguments, but I found him to be convincing and slightly more open-minded than I had originally assumed. The open-minded quality that I am referring to is visible in his assessment that the sexual “holding back” that women were (and are) subjected to inevitably has a negative impact.
Regarding men, Freud theorizes that in order to properly fuse sensuality and affection they must somehow debase their “sexual object.” Here we have an eerie psychological description of the gaze and the object of the gaze. The woman who has classically been the object of the male gaze has been debased. She is the passive object while the male is the powerful and active viewer.

Cixous
Cixous’ essay is a complete stylistic departure from Freud. And I think this is her point, not necessarily Freud in particular – but she offers an alternative to patriarchic ways of writing. She says, “I will say: today, writing is woman’s. Her monologue is so strikingly filled with metaphor and therefore expects to be understood almost intuitively.
An especially beautiful piece of her essay was the description of “bisexuality.” I took this to mean that women, unfortunately more than men, have the unique power of existing in both the realms of masculinity and femininity. They can do so, because they don’t feel the societal threat of emasculation and this gives them the power of multiplicity in addition to enabling women to experience and learn more.

Mulvey
Mulvey uses psychoanalysis to show how film has been structured by patriarchal society. She states that she is using psychoanalysis in order to use a patriarchic system or deconstruction and thus begin to create an alternative language. By analyzing the structure of film she aims to destroy current methods and make way for the conception of “a new language of desire.”
She begins with Freud’s theory on scopophilia and points out that the scopophilic gaze is an active “taking of other people as objects.” The separation of the audience or the voyeurs results in a repression, which is in turn projected onto the performer. But, the audience also identifies with the performer or has a narcissistic reaction to projected image.
Both of these can happen within the scope of a narrative film. The male viewer either recognizes himself in the protagonist or identifies his object of desire in the main female character. So, what happens in so-called “chick flicks”? I would guess that some women identify with and see themselves in the female protagonist and see the main male character as their object of desire. This is of course very basic and hugely stereotypical, but it goes back to Cixous’ argument of bisexuality in women. Men generally tend not to like chick flicks (possible due to a fear of emasculation) whereas women tend to accept and even like the typical Hollywood film where the male is the usual protagonist. Is this because women are more able to be “bisexual” or because women have adapted too well to the idea of woman as object? And this is what I think Mulvey is trying to destroy in a way: the only identifiable character for women is the “woman [who does not have] the slightest importance.”

Mercer
Mercer deconstructs the sexual and racial components of Mapplethorpe’s photographs of black men by using three codes. The first is sculptural and relates to classically idealized statues as well as the Greek athlete and the modern day athlete - doubly so because the subject is black and thus a reminder of the heroic “black man’s body.” Unfortunately, the other stereotype of the black male criminal is a component of the sculptural as well. Either way the subject is seen as an object. The second code is portraiture, which is non-confrontational and therefore plays into old rules of colonialism and thus the portrait is passive in relation to the active viewer. The third code is cropping and lighting, which serve to break apart the body of the subject and is seen in some feminist theories as an act of violence. These three codes act to “aestheticize” stereotypes into works of art. Mercer says that the “visual codification...reveals more about the desires of the hidden and invisible white male subject behind the camera, and what “he” wants to see, than it does about the anonymous black men whose beautiful bodies we see depicted.” Does this mean that Mapplethorpe’s photographs somehow serve to de-rieify the fetishization of the black male by revealing the character of the desire behind the object?

Rajan
Rajan says that she aims to explore “how a western meditation on the subject of the body in pain may be appropriated for and contested by a specific historical and feminist project in the interests of the female subject as agent.” What I found in her discussion regarding Sati is the problem in separating what is considered tradition and what is considered modern. The act of sati can’t be placed in either realm because its practice has changed over time and because it is tradition that exists in the modern. The western initiated attempt to outlaw sati has not been entirely successful and may have in fact been cause for the act to be seen in higher regard. Thus, imperial laws or laws meant to control or repress don’t necessarily result in the “correct” actions of those they are meant to effect. Therefore, Rajan argues for an investigation into the “subjective pain” and “objective spectacle.” These terms can be directly related to a feminist interest in agency as well as objectification.

Butler
Butler discusses the ways in which it is difficult for a language of feminism to emerge due to the origination of the subject “woman” from a patriarchal discourse. Additionally, it is impossible to define “woman” within a feminist discourse because the defining would serve to work against the aims of feminism in the first place. She says, “if one “is” a woman, that is surely not all one is; the term fails to be exhaustive...because gender is always constituted coherently or consistently in different historical contexts, and because gender intersects with racial, class, ethnic, sexual, and regional modalities of discursively constituted identities.” In some ways this is a political weakness of feminism because it makes it impossible to define it within political, cut and dry terms. Yet, it is also strength because it allows for and calls for an evolving definition, somewhat akin to Couxis’ description of bisexuality. However, here, feminism takes on the multiple identities. So, the possible inability of feminism to have a political representation is conversely a strength because it refuses to be locked into one definition.

Bhabha
Bhabha was the most difficult to understand, but it seems that he is concerned with moving past modernity into postmodernity unconsciously - or in a way that doesn't acknowledge the mistakes of the past and thus continues on without a full understanding of self and therefore an ethnocentric perspective of discourse.

No comments: