This week I was most interested and excited by Freud's "On the Universal Tendency to Debasement" and "Sorties" by Helene Cixous. For me, I think it is always interesting to read about the opposite sex, of both sexes for that matter, because it is generally something you can relate to or have seen. As for race, Rajan's "The Subject of Sati: Pain and Death in the Contemporary Discourse on Sati" was really a question on ethics and morality. When does the law jump in? Should it? Is it an imposition on someone else's beliefs, or it is forced suicide?
What I found most interesting about Freud and Cixous was their claim on the ways males identify themselves, resulting in a preoccupation with the phallus and a fear of castration. In both writings, the males' identifying source of manhood is the penis. If he's psychical impotent or is open and accepting of the "other" ( the "other" being female and associated with female traits which Cixous suggests that all of us have bits of the "other" in us) then he is threatened with castration. Freud goes into detail about how psychical impotence occurs when the affectionate and sensual currents do not unite. Psychical impotence therefore can affect the way a man loves. For example, there are those men whose sensual current avoided the affectionate current, and although they may be physically successful when it comes to sex, they do not get any particular pleasure. Then Freud brings up another problem, "the man almost always feels his respect for the woman acting as a restriction on his sexual activity, and only develops full potency when he is with a defaced sexual object." (152) This insinuation goes along with Laura Mulvey's article about women in the cinema, and also Matthews essay from last week on how women portrayed on the screen and in art allows for the male to project his own fantasies upon them, granting them sexual gratification and pleasure.
Cixous states that "pairs of oppositions are couples" (158), for example, "active/passive," "male/female." She then states that "sexual difference is treated by coupling it with its opposite." (158) According to Cixous the "other" is in all of us, referring to this as "bisexuality." Once one can accept the other within, one can create and be free. She uses the example of writing, and how when women write, it is a true expression of self and body because of their ability to embrace their "other." The man, however, in some cases is socially fated and can only embrace the "I" of the phallus, making him horrified of homosexuality and castration. Again, going back to Freud. Cixous poses the question that she says stumps Freud, "Why the refusal?" She already said that man has the "grotesque and unenviable fate of being recluded to a single idol with clay balls." (161) This fate causes an obsession with the phallus, as it is what men use to identify themselves as men. Man fears the acceptance of the "other" (femininity) because he feels that with the acceptance he will lose his identity and then is no longer man resulting in castration. If they cannot identify themselves as man, then they are in their eyes "reduced" to the "other"- feminine. Identity for man is seen through the phallus. If castration occurs, resulting in femininity, identity is lost. So, I think it is something within a man that causes the fear of castration and the "other." I do not think it has to with society since most if not all are patriarchal, and not all men have this trouble, so I think it must be something innate within that causes this refusal.
Monday, October 15, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment