Ideology is a belief system. It is bound up in politics, domination and power. It is an expression of class interests, particularly of those in power who represent their own interests as universal and so natural that we need not question them. And yet, it represents a system whose self-perpetuation is so important that it will be maintained “peaceable if we can, forcibly if we must.” (35)
If we follow the trajectory of the readings, ideology has transmuted from the time of Marx and Engels (1846) from a place from which individuals become” conscious of conflict and can fight it out” to something that in the 20st century has become so pervasive, permeating all aspects of our daily existence, that it is only in dreams, through the unconscious, that we can recognize it and resist it (Zizek, 1989)
.
Beginning with Marx the groundwork is laid for our discussion. The economic mode of production determines the political and legal superstructure of society, the social consciousness and the social classes of individuals. In turn, ideology is determined by who people are and their place in society. Marx and Engels define ideology as the interests of a class expressed as ideas. Within the ruling class are mental and material laborers. The ideologists (mental laborers) form the “illusions of the class about itself.” Jae Emerling, in discussing Althusser in Theory for Art History, calls this “the narrative or story we tell ourselves in order to understand our relationship to the modes of production.” (60). It is not that other members of society are thought-less, but it is the ideologists of the ruling class who control the message and the official means of disseminating that message.
Which brings us to Althusser who defines ideology as both an illusion and an allusion. The real world is not represented in ideology. Instead, like Peirce’s interpretant, it is a mental concept based on something real. According to Althusser, ideology interpellates individuals as subjects. We are “hailed,” we recognize that we are the object (subject?) of the hailing and we behave accordingly as dictated by convention. This takes place as a matter of course, and the system perpetuates itself.
Beauvoir, Said and Bhabha all look at the process by which the female and racial “Other” come into being. Beauvoir finds parallels between the relationship of women and of Blacks to the white male master class through which, and by which, everything is defined. Language provides the structure through which ideological concepts of unequal dualities (Self/other, Insider/outsider, Male/female, Subject/object) are produced. Said shows how the Orient is defined by a lack, by what is missing in the West. It is a fictionalizing of a culture to serve the needs of the West. What the Orient really is is forgotten in the process. Bhabha (from what I can gather) emphasizes the “other” as both an object of derision and of desire. What comes to mind for me is a Freudian/Lacanian maneuver in which white males mentally split off the parts of themselves that are threatening and that cannot be tolerated and project these characteristics onto something outside of themselves. (Blacks/women are lazy, childlike, amoral, incapable of governing themselves etc.) But these lost parts are secretly missed and desired even though this cannot be acknowledged consciously. He talks about stereotypes as being ambivalent in character. On the one hand, they are fixed and unchanging but on the other hand they are ambiguous and must be anxiously repeated as if they can never quite be proven.
What is frightening to me is what Zizek calls the “success” of ideology. He sites an example of the stereotype of a Jew and what occurs when the stereotype conflicts with the congenial behavior of one’s nice Jewish neighbor. The “objective proof” that would negate the stereotype is turned into an argument to prove its veracity. The nice behavior is just proof of how duplicitous Jews really are. They can hide their real nature behind a false front. When this is the case, it seems the only way to get at the truth or the “hard kernel of the Real” is through dreams and the unconscious.
I’d love to discuss how all of this applies to art. Julia, we could have a great discussion about the Chinese avantgarde, (I have stories to share about Yan Lei), artists of the African diaspora and postcolonialism as it plays out in the art museum. Hopefully there will be time for these topics in future classes.
Monday, September 17, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I thought you might have stories having worked at the Cantor. Please do share....
Post a Comment