What do I know about ideology that I didn’t know before this weekend? Better yet, what can I say about ideology that I couldn’t say before? This week’s reading explored different concepts of ideology. The editors do not define ideology. They claim it’s too hard to define ideology and they provide us with various samples so that we can see the complexity and range involved with defining and explaining ideology. For me, ideology is a system of beliefs that is shaped by our own life experiences. Our ideologies may be shared, but for the most part they differ and in some cases these differences bring about real conflict. As we go through life and different experiences, we may become more entrenched with our ideologies or we may cast them off and adopt new ones.
While reading the discussions by Marx and Engels it is easy to see how class and social structure shape one’s ideology. Individuals in union jobs are going to have a different set of beliefs about life and the working world then those who are not in unions. We are not born with these beliefs and feelings, it is our life experiences that shape and mould them. Marx and Engels discussions also invoked ideas about political ideologies. We can either accept the current political ideologies or we can reject them and follow other ideologies or develop our own. In the U.S. we tend to have a peaceful acceptance or rejection of ideologies. Violence and conflict occurs when ideologies are opposed in a non-peaceful manner.
This leads us into Althusser’s discussion about ideology and his concept of Ideological State Apparatuses and Repressive State Apparatuses. Repressive State Apparatuses function through violence. In a discussion I had today with a friend about Sadam Hussein and Iraq, we noted that Hussein ruled with an iron fist. He was repressive. He kept those who did not follow his beliefs in line through violence and intimidation.
Althusser’s discussion about the imaginary nature of ideology was also very interesting. The concept of illusion and allusion is something that should not be overlooked when discussing ideology. When reading this I was reminded of a discussion from my youth group when our teacher pointed out to us that we often think we are close to heaven but in fact we still have a long ways to go. This idea that we are good, this ideology that we are good perfect Christians is illusionary. (On a side note, I have to comment about the last part of Althusser’s writing. I began to lose focus on what he was saying and soon began to keep track of the structure of his sentences. In one sentence he used ideas 3 times and ideology 4 times. In another sentence he used ideology 6 times. It seems to me the point he was trying to make was so complex that even he was having a hard time trying to make it coherent!)
The last readings concerned gender and race. The one word I didn’t see come up in these discussions was prejudice. It seems to me the point these authors were trying to make were the flaws that exist in the ideologies of gender, race, and religion. I found Said’s discussion about the development and definition of Orientalism interesting. He pointed out the flaws that are a result of the “White Man” defining Orientalism. While reading Said, I couldn’t help but think about the embarrassing performance by Mickey Rooney as Mr. Yunioshi in Breakfast at Tiffany’s. His outrageous portrayal of an “Oriental” was based completely on stereotypes of Asians as developed by the “White Man.” As people today ask that Mark Twain’s Hukleberry Finn be pulled from high school reading lists because of the use of the “n” word, I wonder why they don’t also ask that Breakfast at Tiffany’s be pulled from the public’s view or at least cut Rooney’s scenes.
To sum up, I see that the discussions about ideology can be endless and that today’s artists are continually challenging us to think about the various ideologies that exist and surround us in our world.
Tuesday, September 18, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment