In doing the readings this week I’m reminded of my son who as a toddler was fascinated with butterflies. He caught them and tore them apart trying to discover what they were made of and how they worked. He was disappointed when he found no secrets and cried inconsolably when he was unable to put the pieces back together and make them fly again. On the one hand I am mourning for a world where humans believed they could communicate directly with nature and where there were simple overriding narratives that explained the world and one’s place and purpose within it. On the other hand, I think it is good for people previously left out of universal narratives to have a voice and for the underlying and unspoken assumptions behind those discourses to be exposed. I am just afraid that through the constant and unrelenting process of exposing, deconstructing and critiquing, exemplified by this week’s readings, that I’ll end up like my son, inconsolable if I am unable to mentally put the parts back together again and get on with life.
Lyotard tells us that the postmodern condition is one without an overriding narrative. There is no single story that makes sense of the value of knowledge throughout history, whether it is a political story of emancipation of the people through scientific knowledge, or a philosophical one where knowledge is an end in itself.
Baudrillard says we are so far from reality that we have created a hyperreality instead, a third level simulation in which any reference to “reality” has been replaced with signs. In “Theory for Art History,” Jae Emerling defines a 1st level simulacrum (an image or representation of something) as something that masks reality like Baroque art that valued artifice over realism. Second order simulacra appeared in the modern age of mass production. In postmodernity, 3rd level simulations appear that have no intrinsic or causal connection with what was previously considered to be reality. The simulacrum supercedes the real so that we live in a world of representations of representations (89). Baudrillard cites Disneyland as an example. Interestingly, although Disneyland is based on the founder’s memory of the small town of his childhood, Marcelina Missouri, Salvador Dali was actually important in its creation. It is a constructed space of social control meant to teach American values in which the past is presented as fantasy. Baudrillard goes so far as to say that Disneyland is the “real” America. Its presence conceals the fact that what is outside its gates is in fact a simulation and is not “real” at all.
Lyotard in “The Inhuman” presents us with a real event beyond human intervention, thought and control. The explosion of the sun would end life as we know it and would thus make all other discussions moot. So how do we deal with this eventuality? Do we ignore it and continue to live our human-centered lives of the mind and the body or do we plan for an unknowable and unforeseeable future in which the systems we have created allow “thought” to remain possible after a disaster that destroys humans?
Lyotard introduces the word sublation. “There is no sublation, no deferral if nothing survives” (222). Sublation means to destroy and to preserve. It unites something with its opposite. This term is instructive in understanding Derrida’s essay on “The Gift of Death.” Derrida introduces another unthinkable situation: that of a father, Abraham, who would sacrifice Isaac his irreplaceable and beloved son to God because he is asked to do so without explanation. He would do it keeping his intentions a secret to prove his absolute duty to God. Derrida describes is as an aporia, a paradox that unites binary opposites. In the instant that the act would occur, the boundary between love and hate dissolves. Abraham’s love for his son becomes hate allowing the act to occur although the character of love never wavers. The gift to God loses its reciprocity. Abraham expects nothing in return for this sacrifice. Duty, responsibility and human ethics are all transcended. Derrida ends by saying: ”An infanticide father who hides what he going to do from his son and his family without knowing why, what could be more abominable, what mystery… more frightful… vis-à-vis love, humanity, the family, or morality?” The paradox is how to act morally, ethically, responsibly, without self-interest in relation to the Other (here God) within a Hegelian and Kierkegaardian system. Perhaps it is an impossibility.
Baudrillard and Zizek discuss another unthinkable situation, the bombing of the Twin Towers on 9/11/2001. For Baudrillard it is the impact of the images of 9/11 that we retain. Although the destruction of the Twin Towers was unimaginable, that was not enough to make it “real.” Although it created havoc and destruction, Baudrillard sees it as a symbolic act. (Are we back to Lacan’s Real, Imaginary and Symbolic?) Its repercussions are that the distinction between the crime and crackdown has disappeared. He says the Western ideology of freedom has been replaced with police state globalization, law and order measures that the US and others are implementing, internalizing their own defeat in the name of security. He sees no remedy. The war on terrorism and conventional warfare are rhetorical rehashings of the past. Zizek calls the repetition of 9/11 images “jouissance” beyond the pleasure principle. The real has been emptied from these iconic symbols. We have seen them so many times before in movies. Your worst nightmare, envisioned through the cinema has come to pass in New York so we look to Hollywood (part of Althusser’s ISA, ideological state apparatus) to know how to deal with it. With 9/11 reality was not shattered by the image. Instead the image shattered our fiction of reality. Welcome to “The Matrix” and the desert of the real.
Monday, November 12, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment