Sunday, September 9, 2007

Mieke Bal and Semiotics

I found this to be a very dense article! I am looking forward to the class discussion on this.
As I understand it, Mieke Bal is interested in moving beyond the confines of traditional narratives to find a fresh view, a new way of interpreting narrative artworks based on literary sources, in this case Judith and Holofernes. She wants us to put the image first, to focus on what we actually see, using the system of semiotics to reinterpret the signs within the image and understand the process of how these create meaning.

She spends a lot of time laying the groundwork, defining (and refining) her terms. She took what I thought was clear after last week’s discussion of Peirce and overlaid it with layers of complexity. (I liken my mental state to her description of the confusion of arms and legs around the still center of the detached head in Artemesia’s “Judith Slaying Holofernes”.) I am hoping greater clarity and insight ultimately emerge from my confusion.

In addition to the icon, index and symbol, which she describes in detail, we now have the sign/representamen, the mental image/interpretant and the object/referent and the ground of the representamen, the basis upon which interpretation takes place. She emphasizes that the assigning of meaning is a subjective process but that meaning is produced through reference to the outside world not merely by differences between signs. (I think this is where she and Peirce differ from Saussure.) That we assign meaning to signs, i.e. that we read them, makes them work as signs.

The semiotic tools she chooses to work with are Barthes’ reader/viewer centered codes of narration and Bakhtin’s polyphony based on the view of the writer/artist. This view makes us aware of the fact that images are not unified. Evidence of multiple discourses existing in the culture of the writer/artist inevitably make their presence known in the work of art. Also, looking at a painting is a dynamic process with different interrelated viewing positions embedded in the artwork. As we know from Lacan’s concept of the eye and the gaze, determining who is the object of whose gaze can be a complex issue. In “The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis” he says: “You never look at me from the place from which I see you.”

So how can a semiotic perspective and Bal’s set of tools help us read images?
In Caravaggio’s “Judith Beheading Holofernes”, she focuses on the disjunctures in the image to find a new way of interpreting it. We have an enigma to solve by looking at the clues provided in the painting. Judith beheads Holofernes but who causes whose suffering? Is Judith a hero or a wicked seductress? Is Holofernes a tragic victim or the perpetrator? After looking at Dottie Attie’s postmodernist “A Violent Child” that repositions both figures, she sees Judith as a sign for the victims of violence. Like Paris Hilton or like the photos in The Family of Man, Judith becomes a symbol, an empty referent to be filled in. So Bal uses something from the present, Attie’s painting, to understand and reinterpret an image from the past. I am not sure that I agree with her interpretation of the causality of the stripes of blood spurting from Holofernes’ neck and the rhyming black and white striped sword but I would have to see the original painting or a better reproduction to be sure.

In Artemesia’s versions of Judith, and in her self portrait, the women have more agency. They are given strong physical presences. They are passionate, committed, determined. Bal gives great significance to the sign of the hand combined with the use of light in these paintings. She calls the hand “the new addition to Genteleschi’s epistemology.” The work of the hand is connected to the work of the mind by the light focusing on both. (My interpretation, not hers.) I think she would say that it is how we read the signs within the image itself that is important.

No comments: